| Game | Correct Pick | Member Pick | |
| 1. | Buffalo 31
Charlotte 9 (15.5)
Final | Buffalo | Buffalo |  |
| 2. | Utah State 41
Kent State 51 (58)
Final | Kent State | Utah State |  |
| 3. | Central Michigan 11 (14.5)
San Diego State 48
Final | San Diego State | Central Michigan | |
| 4. | Liberty 23 (28)
Georgia Southern 16
Final | Liberty | Georgia Southern | |
| 5. | SMU 28
Florida Atlantic 52 (55)
Final | Florida Atlantic | SMU | |
| 6. | Florida International 26 (28.5)
Arkansas State 34
Final | Arkansas State | Arkansas State | |
| 7. | Boise State 7 (10.5)
Washington 38
Final | Washington | Washington | |
| 8. | Appalachian State 31
UAB 17 (34)
Final | UAB | Appalachian State | |
| 9. | UCF 48
Marshall 25 (42)
Final | UCF | Marshall | |
| 10. | Hawai'i 38 (39.5)
BYU 34
Final | Hawai'i | Hawai'i | |
| 11. | Louisiana Tech 14 (20)
Miami 0
Final | Louisiana Tech | Miami | |
| 12. | Pittsburgh 34
Eastern Michigan 30 (40.5)
Final | Eastern Michigan | Pittsburgh | |
| 13. | North Carolina 55
Temple 13 (18)
Final | North Carolina | North Carolina | |
| 14. | Michigan State 27
Wake Forest 21 (26)
Final | Michigan State | Wake Forest | |
| 15. | Oklahoma State 21 (28)
Texas A&M 24
Final | Oklahoma State | Texas A&M | |
| 16. | USC 24 (25.5)
Iowa 49
Final | Iowa | Iowa | |
| 17. | Air Force 31
Washington State 21 (23.5)
Final | Air Force | Washington State | |
| 18. | Memphis 39 (45.5)
Penn State 53
Final | Penn State | Penn State | |
| 19. | Notre Dame 33
Iowa State 9 (13)
Final | Notre Dame | Iowa State | |
| 20. | Oklahoma 28 (40.5)
LSU 63
Final | LSU | LSU | |
| 21. | Clemson 29
Ohio State 23 (25)
Final | Clemson | Clemson | |
| 22. | Western Kentucky 23
Western Michigan 20 (23.5)
Final | Western Michigan | Western Michigan | |
| 23. | Mississippi State 28
Louisville 38 (42)
Final | Louisville | Mississippi State | |
| 24. | California 35
Illinois 20 (27)
Final | California | Illinois | |
| 25. | Florida 36
Virginia 28 (42)
Final | Virginia | Florida | |
| 26. | Virginia Tech 30
Kentucky 37 (40)
Final | Kentucky | Kentucky | |
| 27. | Florida State 14 (19)
Arizona State 20
Final | Arizona State | Florida State | |
| 28. | Navy 20
Kansas State 17 (19)
Final | Navy | Kansas State | |
| 29. | Wyoming 38
Georgia State 17 (24.5)
Final | Wyoming | Georgia State | |
| 30. | Utah 10
Texas 38 (45.5)
Final | Texas | Texas | |
| 31. | Minnesota 31 (38)
Auburn 24
Final | Minnesota | Auburn | |
| 32. | Oregon 28 (31)
Wisconsin 27
Final | Oregon | Oregon | |
| 33. | Georgia 26
Baylor 14 (21.5)
Final | Georgia | Baylor | |
| 34. | Boston College 6 (13)
Cincinnati 38
Final | Cincinnati | Cincinnati | |
| 35. | Indiana 22 (23.5)
Tennessee 23
Final | Indiana | Tennessee | |
| 36. | Ohio 30
Nevada 21 (28.5)
Final | Ohio | Ohio | |
| 37. | Southern Mississippi 13 (20)
Tulane 30
Final | Tulane | Tulane | |
| 38. | Louisiana 27
Miami (OH) 17 (31)
Final | Miami (OH) | Louisiana | |
| 39. | Clemson 25 (30.5)
LSU 42
Final | LSU | LSU | |
*Scores in parenthesis include additional points spotted to the underdog.
Total Members: