| Game | Correct Pick | Member Pick | |
| 1. | Arizona 45
New Mexico 37 (46.5)
Final | New Mexico | Arizona |  |
| 2. | BYU 28 (30.5)
Utah 35
Final | Utah | Utah |  |
| 3. | Ohio 29 (37.5)
Appalachian State 31
Final | Ohio | Ohio | |
| 4. | San José State 27
Georgia State 16 (19.5)
Final | San José State | Georgia State | |
| 5. | Arkansas State 28 (30)
Louisiana Tech 47
Final | Louisiana Tech | Louisiana Tech | |
| 6. | Western Kentucky 45
South Florida 35 (38)
Final | Western Kentucky | Western Kentucky | |
| 7. | Akron 23 (30)
Utah State 21
Final | Akron | Utah State | |
| 8. | Temple 17
Toledo 32 (33.5)
Final | Toledo | Temple | |
| 9. | Boise State 55
Northern Illinois 7 (15)
Final | Boise State | Boise State | |
| 10. | Georgia Southern 58 (65.5)
Bowling Green 27
Final | Georgia Southern | Bowling Green | |
| 11. | Middle Tennessee 31 (34)
Western Michigan 45
Final | Western Michigan | Middle Tennessee | |
| 12. | San Diego State 42 (43.5)
Cincinnati 7
Final | San Diego State | Cincinnati | |
| 13. | Connecticut 10 (14.5)
Marshall 16
Final | Marshall | Marshall | |
| 14. | Miami (FL) 14 (17)
Washington State 20
Final | Washington State | Washington State | |
| 15. | Washington 44
Southern Mississippi 31 (39.5)
Final | Washington | Washington | |
| 16. | Indiana 41
Duke 44 (46)
Final/OT | Duke | Indiana | |
| 17. | Tulsa 52 (65.5)
Virginia Tech 55
Final | Tulsa | Tulsa | |
| 18. | UCLA 29
Nebraska 37 (44)
Final | Nebraska | UCLA | |
| 19. | Pittsburgh 28 (31.5)
Navy 44
Final | Navy | Navy | |
| 20. | Central Michigan 14 (19.5)
Minnesota 21
Final | Minnesota | Minnesota | |
| 21. | California 55
Air Force 36 (43)
Final | California | California | |
| 22. | North Carolina 38 (41)
Baylor 49
Final | Baylor | Baylor | |
| 23. | Nevada 28 (31)
Colorado State 23
Final | Nevada | Colorado State | |
| 24. | LSU 56
Texas Tech 27 (34.5)
Final | LSU | LSU | |
| 25. | Auburn 31
Memphis 10 (12.5)
Final | Auburn | Memphis | |
| 26. | NC State 28 (33.5)
Mississippi State 51
Final | Mississippi State | Mississippi State | |
| 27. | Texas A&M 21
Louisville 27 (28)
Final | Louisville | Texas A&M | |
| 28. | USC 21
Wisconsin 23 (26)
Final | Wisconsin | Wisconsin | |
| 29. | Houston 38 (45.5)
Florida State 24
Final | Houston | Florida State | |
| 30. | Oklahoma 17
Clemson 37 (41)
Final | Clemson | Clemson | |
| 31. | Michigan State 0 (9.5)
Alabama 38
Final | Alabama | Alabama | |
| 32. | Northwestern 6 (14.5)
Tennessee 45
Final | Tennessee | Tennessee | |
| 33. | Michigan 41
Florida 7 (11.5)
Final | Michigan | Michigan | |
| 34. | Notre Dame 28 (35)
Ohio State 44
Final | Ohio State | Ohio State | |
| 35. | Stanford 45
Iowa 16 (23)
Final | Stanford | Stanford | |
| 36. | Oklahoma State 20 (27.5)
Ole Miss 48
Final | Ole Miss | Ole Miss | |
| 37. | Penn State 17 (24)
Georgia 24
Final | | Georgia | |
| 38. | Kansas State 23 (34.5)
Arkansas 45
Final | Arkansas | Kansas State | |
| 39. | Oregon 41 (41)
TCU 47
Final/3OT | TCU | Oregon | |
| 40. | West Virginia 43 (43)
Arizona State 42
Final | West Virginia | West Virginia | |
| 41. | Alabama 45
Clemson 40 (47)
Final | Clemson | Alabama | |
*Scores in parenthesis include additional points spotted to the underdog.
Total Members: