| Game | Correct Pick | Member Pick | |
| 1. | Army 13
Navy 17 (24.5)
Final | Navy | Navy |  |
| 2. | Middle Tennessee 31 (41)
Toledo 24
Final | Middle Tennessee | Middle Tennessee | |
| 3. | Northern Illinois 41 (51)
Coastal Carolina 47
Final | Northern Illinois | Coastal Carolina |  |
| 4. | Western Kentucky 59 (61.5)
Appalachian State 38
Final | Western Kentucky | Appalachian State | |
| 5. | UTEP 24 (35)
Fresno State 31
Final | UTEP | Fresno State | |
| 6. | UAB 31 (38)
BYU 28
Final | UAB | BYU | |
| 7. | Eastern Michigan 20 (28.5)
Liberty 56
Final | Liberty | Liberty | |
| 8. | Utah State 24 (31)
Oregon State 13
Final | Utah State | Utah State | |
| 9. | Louisiana 36
Marshall 21 (27)
Final | Louisiana | Louisiana | |
| 10. | Old Dominion 17 (26.5)
Tulsa 30
Final | Tulsa | Tulsa | |
| 11. | Kent State 38 (41)
Wyoming 52
Final | Wyoming | Kent State | |
| 12. | UTSA 24
San Diego State 38 (40.5)
Final | San Diego State | UTSA | |
| 13. | Missouri 22 (25.5)
Army 24
Final | Missouri | Missouri | |
| 14. | North Texas 14 (17.5)
Miami (OH) 27
Final | Miami (OH) | North Texas | |
| 15. | UCF 29 (36.5)
Florida 17
Final | UCF | UCF | |
| 16. | Memphis 0
Hawai'i 0 (0)
Final | | Memphis | |
| 17. | Georgia State 51
Ball State 20 (24.5)
Final | Georgia State | Georgia State | |
| 18. | Western Michigan 52 (53)
Nevada 24
Final | Western Michigan | Western Michigan | |
| 19. | Boston College 0
East Carolina 0 (0)
Final | | Boston College | |
| 20. | Houston 17 (20)
Auburn 13
Final | Houston | Houston | |
| 21. | Air Force 31 (32.5)
Louisville 28
Final | Air Force | Air Force | |
| 22. | Mississippi State 7
Texas Tech 34 (42.5)
Final | Texas Tech | Mississippi State | |
| 23. | UCLA 0 (0)
NC State 0
Final | | UCLA | |
| 24. | West Virginia 6 (9.5)
Minnesota 18
Final | Minnesota | Minnesota | |
| 25. | SMU 0 (0)
Virginia 0
Final | | SMU | |
| 26. | Maryland 54 (55)
Virginia Tech 10
Final | Maryland | Virginia Tech | |
| 27. | Clemson 20 (21)
Iowa State 13
Final | Clemson | Clemson | |
| 28. | Oregon 32 (36)
Oklahoma 47
Final | Oklahoma | Oklahoma | |
| 29. | North Carolina 21
South Carolina 38 (45)
Final | South Carolina | South Carolina | |
| 30. | Tennessee 45
Purdue 48 (51)
Final | Purdue | Tennessee | |
| 31. | Pittsburgh 21
Michigan State 31 (34.5)
Final | Michigan State | Michigan State | |
| 32. | Wisconsin 20
Arizona State 13 (20)
Final | | Wisconsin | |
| 33. | Wake Forest 0 (0)
Texas A&M 0
Final | | Texas A&M | |
| 34. | Washington State 0 (0)
Miami 0
Final | | Miami | |
| 35. | Central Michigan 0 (0)
Boise State 0
Final | | Central Michigan | |
| 36. | Cincinnati 0 (98)
Alabama 98
Final | | Alabama | |
| 37. | Georgia 34
Michigan 11 (18.5)
Final | Georgia | Georgia | |
| 38. | Penn State 10
Arkansas 24 (26.5)
Final | Arkansas | Arkansas | |
| 39. | Oklahoma State 37 (39.5)
Notre Dame 35
Final | Oklahoma State | Oklahoma State | |
| 40. | Iowa 17 (19.5)
Kentucky 20
Final | Kentucky | Kentucky | |
| 41. | Utah 45 (51.5)
Ohio State 48
Final | Utah | Ohio State | |
| 42. | Baylor 21
Ole Miss 7 (8)
Final | Baylor | Ole Miss | |
| 43. | LSU 20
Kansas State 42 (44.5)
Final | Kansas State | LSU | |
*Scores in parenthesis include additional points spotted to the underdog.
Total Members: