Crimson Red Sports

Around Campus => The Quad => Topic started by: WALL-E on September 25, 2017, 03:38:02 PM



Title: "Confusion followed roughing the passer flag on Alabama LB"
Post by: WALL-E on September 25, 2017, 03:38:02 PM
Confusion followed roughing the passer flag on Alabama LB
(http://media.al.com/alabamafootball_impact/photo/jenningsflagjpg-aea28c9b529ff715.jpg)Alabama LB Anfernee Jennings was flagged for roughing the passer at Vanderbilt.

Read more...


Title: Re: "Confusion followed roughing the passer flag on Alabama LB"
Post by: Chechem on September 25, 2017, 03:47:44 PM
Quote
"I felt like he kind of jumped a little bit, and that caused me to go lower," Jennings said. "I just have to tackle up high when I'm pressuring the quarterback." ...

I knew why we got the penalty, but the rule needs to encompass movement of the QB.  If he's running or jumping backwards (as he was), then he isn't going to be injured by a low tackle. 

The injury comes from a QB being hit while standing upright in the pocket or stepping forward into a throw.  That was the situation that injured Tom Brady and so many others.  This instance was evidence that a tackler can't always choose the position of his tackle.  If the QB is moving backwards the rule shouldn't apply.


Title: Re: "Confusion followed roughing the passer flag on Alabama LB"
Post by: ricky023 on September 25, 2017, 04:21:06 PM
Quote
"I felt like he kind of jumped a little bit, and that caused me to go lower," Jennings said. "I just have to tackle up high when I'm pressuring the quarterback." ...

I knew why we got the penalty, but the rule needs to encompass movement of the QB.  If he's running or jumping backwards (as he was), then he isn't going to be injured by a low tackle. 

The injury comes from a QB being hit while standing upright in the pocket or stepping forward into a throw.  That was the situation that injured Tom Brady and so many others.  This instance was evidence that a tackler can't always choose the position of his tackle.  If the QB is moving backwards the rule shouldn't apply.



 :clap: :clap: totally agree with this. ^^^ because no way if he jumps a man can change his direction. RTR!


Title: Re: "Confusion followed roughing the passer flag on Alabama LB"
Post by: Catch Prothro on September 26, 2017, 07:53:13 AM
Quote
"I felt like he kind of jumped a little bit, and that caused me to go lower," Jennings said. "I just have to tackle up high when I'm pressuring the quarterback." ...

I knew why we got the penalty, but the rule needs to encompass movement of the QB.  If he's running or jumping backwards (as he was), then he isn't going to be injured by a low tackle. 

The injury comes from a QB being hit while standing upright in the pocket or stepping forward into a throw.  That was the situation that injured Tom Brady and so many others.  This instance was evidence that a tackler can't always choose the position of his tackle.  If the QB is moving backwards the rule shouldn't apply.
The rules as currently enforced make it very difficult on the defense.  In addition to the roughing penalty is targeting.  I've seen players flagged and ejected when the runner chose to slide at the last minute, or when a receiver ducked down after a catch.  They expect these defensive players to stop in mid-air.