| Game | Correct Pick | Member Pick | |
1. | New Mexico 23 Texas San Antonio 20 (27) Final | Texas San Antonio | New Mexico | |
2. | Houston 10 San Diego State 34 (37.5) Final | San Diego State | Houston | |
3. | Appalachian State 31 Toledo 28 (29) Final | Appalachian State | Toledo | |
4. | UCF 13 Arkansas State 31 (37) Final | Arkansas State | Arkansas State | |
5. | Southern Mississippi 28 Louisiana Lafayette 21 (24.5) Final | Southern Mississippi | Southern Mississippi | |
6. | Central Michigan 10 (22) Tulsa 55 Final | Tulsa | Central Michigan | |
7. | Memphis 31 (35.5) Western Kentucky 51 Final | Western Kentucky | Western Kentucky | |
8. | BYU 24 Wyoming 21 (29.5) Final | Wyoming | Wyoming | |
9. | Idaho 61 (74.5) Colorado State 50 Final | Idaho | Colorado State | |
10. | Eastern Michigan 20 (23.5) Old Dominion 24 Final | Old Dominion | Old Dominion | |
11. | Louisiana Tech 48 (49) Navy 45 Final | Louisiana Tech | Navy | |
12. | Ohio 23 (26.5) Troy 28 Final | Troy | Troy | |
13. | Hawai'i 52 (52) Middle Tennessee 35 Final | Hawai'i | Middle Tennessee | |
14. | Miami (OH) 16 (28.5) Mississippi State 17 Final | Miami (OH) | Mississippi State | |
15. | Maryland 30 Boston College 36 (38.5) Final | Boston College | Maryland | |
16. | NC State 41 Vanderbilt 17 (21) Final | NC State | Vanderbilt | |
17. | Army 38 North Texas 31 (40.5) Final | North Texas | North Texas | |
18. | Temple 26 Wake Forest 34 (47) Final | Wake Forest | Wake Forest | |
19. | Minnesota 17 (23.5) Washington State 12 Final | Minnesota | Washington State | |
20. | Boise State 12 Baylor 31 (39) Final | Baylor | Baylor | |
21. | Pittsburgh 24 Northwestern 31 (36) Final | Northwestern | Pittsburgh | |
22. | West Virginia 14 (17) Miami 31 Final | Miami | Miami | |
23. | Indiana 24 (32) Utah 26 Final | Indiana | Utah | |
24. | Texas A&M 28 Kansas State 33 (35) Final | Kansas State | Texas A&M | |
25. | South Florida 46 South Carolina 39 (49.5) Final | South Carolina | South Carolina | |
26. | Arkansas 24 (31) Virginia Tech 35 Final | Virginia Tech | Virginia Tech | |
27. | Oklahoma State 38 (41) Colorado 8 Final | Oklahoma State | Oklahoma State | |
28. | Georgia 31 TCU 23 (24) Final | Georgia | TCU | |
29. | Stanford 25 North Carolina 23 (26.5) Final | North Carolina | North Carolina | |
30. | Nebraska 24 (27) Tennessee 38 Final | Tennessee | Tennessee | |
31. | South Alabama 21 (33.5) Air Force 45 Final | Air Force | South Alabama | |
32. | Michigan 32 Florida State 33 (40) Final | Florida State | Michigan | |
33. | LSU 29 Louisville 9 (12.5) Final | LSU | LSU | |
34. | Georgia Tech 33 Kentucky 18 (21.5) Final | Georgia Tech | Kentucky | |
35. | Ohio State 0 Clemson 31 (34.5) Final | Clemson | Clemson | |
36. | Florida 30 Iowa 3 (5.5) Final | Florida | Florida | |
37. | Western Michigan 16 (24) Wisconsin 24 Final | | Western Michigan | |
38. | USC 52 Penn State 49 (56) Final | Penn State | Penn State | |
39. | Auburn 19 (24) Oklahoma 35 Final | Oklahoma | Oklahoma | |
*Scores in parenthesis include additional points spotted to the underdog.