Interception, Reception, or Simultaneous Catch?

[SUPERCOACH]

This pic is making the rounds on the inner webz.  Whether the call was right or wrong, it may lead to a rematch if those 2 teams lose a game.  I expect Bama to be #4 in the BCS today.  It is also possible that LSU slips up.  We still have an outside shot at #14 if we handle the rest of our business.

[2Stater]

This pic is making the rounds on the inner webz.  Whether the call was right or wrong, it may lead to a rematch if those 2 teams lose a game.  I expect Bama to be #4 in the BCS today.  It is also possible that LSU slips up.  We still have an outside shot at #14 if we handle the rest of our business.

I voted Bama #1 in the CRS poll. I refuse to let an outcome dictating bad call, lead to any other result. Bama has the better team....period!

[XBAMA]

This pic is making the rounds on the inner webz.  Whether the call was right or wrong, it may lead to a rematch if those 2 teams lose a game.  I expect Bama to be #4 in the BCS today.  It is also possible that LSU slips up.  We still have an outside shot at #14 if we handle the rest of our business.

I voted Bama #1 in the CRS poll. I refuse to let an outcome dictating bad call, lead to any other result. Bama has the better team....period!

HERE ! HERE !    

[SUPERCOACH]

This pic is making the rounds on the inner webz.  Whether the call was right or wrong, it may lead to a rematch if those 2 teams lose a game.  I expect Bama to be #4 in the BCS today.  It is also possible that LSU slips up.  We still have an outside shot at #14 if we handle the rest of our business.

I voted Bama #1 in the CRS poll. I refuse to let an outcome dictating bad call, lead to any other result. Bama has the better team....period!

I have been pondering that myself.  Right now I am leaning toward LSU at #1 because of our kicking game.

[Coach Hank Crisp]

This pic is making the rounds on the inner webz.  Whether the call was right or wrong, it may lead to a rematch if those 2 teams lose a game.  I expect Bama to be #4 in the BCS today.  It is also possible that LSU slips up.  We still have an outside shot at #14 if we handle the rest of our business.

I voted Bama #1 in the CRS poll. I refuse to let an outcome dictating bad call, lead to any other result. Bama has the better team....period!

I have been pondering that myself.  Right now I am leaning toward LSU at #1 because of our kicking game.

I will vote LSU number one in the CRS poll because of our kicking game. Is  our special teams coach Bobby Williams?

[BamaBred]

This pic is making the rounds on the inner webz.  Whether the call was right or wrong, it may lead to a rematch if those 2 teams lose a game.  I expect Bama to be #4 in the BCS today.  It is also possible that LSU slips up.  We still have an outside shot at #14 if we handle the rest of our business.

I voted Bama #1 in the CRS poll. I refuse to let an outcome dictating bad call, lead to any other result. Bama has the better team....period!

I have been pondering that myself.  Right now I am leaning toward LSU at #1 because of our kicking game.

We have a kicking game?

[Catch Prothro]

I think the rule is such that when Williams's rear end hit the ground he was down, with the ball still in both hands, making it a catch and not an interception.  It definitely wasn't a simultaneous catch because Williams had both hands on the ball before LSU defender touched it.  It seems that the refs must be hanging their call on the ball moving in Williams' hands before he hit the ground, but I still think he had possession and was down before the ball was yanked away.

Time to move on from this discussion.  It does provide an agument why Bama should be in the BCSCG if other teams lose, so we may be revisiting it later.

[Reelvalue]

IT WAS A CATCH..AND HE WAS DOWN..IT HAPPENED RIGHT IN FRONT OF MINE, AND HUNDREDS OF OTHER EYES..THE REF THAT MADE THE CALL..HAS MADE OTHER QUESTIONABLE CALLS IN GAMES..

[bama87]

I believe in my heart it was a catch and somebody should send the clip to sec office. That said it is time to move on and get ready for the cowbells. RTR!

[Catch Prothro]

I believe in my heart it was a catch and somebody should send the clip to sec office. That said it is time to move on and get ready for the cowbells. RTR!

Agreed 100%. If the SEC office admits that an officiating mistake was made, that would raise Bama's stock even more.

[SUPERCOACH]

I watched the 4th Qtr a couple of times yesterday.  That is not the only time an LSU defender grabbed the ball away from an Alabama player after they were down.  The Maze bubble screen earlier in that series comes to mind.  All the other times though it was not on a reception as the player was falling to the ground.  The other times everybody ignored the LSU player because the Bama player already had the ball and was running with it.

This is their MO, and it is the reason they have gotten so many turnovers this year.  I am not criticizing them for trying to strip the ball, but if we play them again we need to make sure to hang on to the ball even after we go down, just in case.

[BAMAWV]

Has anyone been listening to PF this afternoon?

[2Stater]

Has anyone been listening to PF this afternoon?

Got my grandson this afternoon. We are watching Mickey Mouse. Same thing. JK. What's going on with PF?

[pmull]

PF talking about Houston Nutt, Penn State scandal and the LSU win. Praising Les Miles and dogging Nick Saban. About what you would expect. He thinks LSU and Bama are the two best teams and a rematch is possible.

[2Stater]

PF talking about Houston Nutt, Penn State scandal and the LSU win. Praising Les Miles and dogging Nick Saban. About what you would expect. He thinks LSU and Bama are the two best teams and a rematch is possible.

How original. 

[Guest]

Username:
Password:
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever

Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

There aren't any users online.

Loading Tweet...